emissions etiketine sahip kayıtlar gösteriliyor. Tüm kayıtları göster
emissions etiketine sahip kayıtlar gösteriliyor. Tüm kayıtları göster

7 Kasım 2016 Pazartesi

Tax meat and dairy to cut emissions and save lives, study urges

Climate taxes on meat and milk would lead to huge and vital cuts in carbon emissions as well as saving half a million lives a year via healthier diets, according to the first global analysis of the issue.


Surcharges of 40% on beef and 20% on milk would account for the damage their production causes people via climate change, an Oxford University team has calculated. These taxes would then deter people from consuming as much of these foods, reducing both emissions and illness, the team said.


Food production causes a quarter of all the greenhouse gas emissions that are driving global warming, largely from the raising of cattle and other livestock. These emissions are increasing as people around the world become richer and eat more meat.


Marco Springmann, from the Oxford Martin Programme on the Future of Food, who led the study, said: “It is clear that if we don’t do something about the emissions from our food system, we have no chance of limiting climate change below 2C.


“But if you’d have to pay 40% more for your steak, you might choose to have it once a week instead of twice.”


Meat and dairy tax

The research, published in the journal Nature Climate Change, evaluated the tax required for each food type to compensate for the climate damage its production causes. Beef has a heavy footprint, due to the deforestation and methane emissions associated with cattle and the grains they are fed, and needed a 40% tax on average across the world.


The scientists then assessed how much less of each food type would be eaten as a result of the taxes. They examined different tax regimes and found the optimum arrangement in terms of both emissions and health was to combine the taxes with subsidies for healthy foods, such as fruit and vegetables, and payments to people to compensate for price increases. This ensured poorer people did not end up with worse diets as the result of taxation.


This optimum tax plan would reduce climate emissions by 1 billion tonnes a year – the same as the entire global aviation industry. This huge potential cut in emissions surprised Springmann, as did the heavy impact of dairy products.


Changes to how food is produced and consumed have largely been ignored in the battle against climate change, due to public sensitivity about their food choices, fears about increasing hunger in poorer parts of the world and the lack of straightforward measures to tackle the problem.


“If people see any food price rise, they get angry, so you have to explain why you are doing it,” said Springmann, adding that a successful food tax policy could spend all the money it raised on ensuring people could afford healthier diets. He said a tax in Denmark on unhealthy saturated fats, where the government simply kept all the revenue, was aborted after a year. But in Mexico, a sugar tax on soft drinks has been successful after the funds were spent on free drinking water in schools.


Most of the foods with big climate impacts also happen to be unhealthy when eaten in large quantities, such as beef and dairy. Therefore, if climate taxes cut consumption, fewer people would die from related diseases such as heart disease, strokes and cancers. In the US, for example, people eat three times the recommended level of meat. The researchers found climate taxes would save more than half a million early deaths every year, largely in Europe, the US, Australia and China.


However, cutting the demand for meat and dairy would not be easy, said Rob Bailey, research director at UK thinktank Chatham House: “The challenge is political. As the new research demonstrates, in many countries there is a very strong public health and climate case for dietary change, but it isn’t happening. Governments are reluctant to ‘interfere’ in people’s lifestyle choices for fear of a public backlash and criticism for ‘nanny statism’, as well as the reaction from powerful interests in the food industry and agricultural lobby.”


Bailey said there was currently little pressure on governments to act, partly because the public understanding of the link between diet and climate change is low. But, when people are informed, they find meat taxes far less unpalatable than is supposed, he said.


Calls to cut meat-eating, by the UN and high-profile figures including climate change experts and the economist Lord Stern, have so far been both rare and controversial.


The new research found the taxes needed to compensate for climate damage were 15% on lamb, 8.5% on chicken, 7% on pork and 5% on eggs. Vegetable oil required a large tax of 25%, but this was due to the low initial price of the product, making a relatively modest surcharge look high.


These tax levels were global averages but there was significant variation with, for example, the beef tax being higher in Latin America, where cattle-raising produces more emissions than in other regions. The optimum tax plan also had regional variations, including limiting climate taxes to beef in the lowest income countries, to ensure people there were still able to afford decent diets.


Springmann said it was critical to find a way to cut the environmental impact of food production: “Either we have climate change and more heart disease, diabetes and obesity, or we do something about the food system.”



Tax meat and dairy to cut emissions and save lives, study urges

7 Ekim 2016 Cuma

Delay to curbs on toxic shipping emissions "would cause 200,000 extra premature deaths"

A push by the shipping and oil industries for a five-year delay to curbs on toxic sulphur emissions would cause an extra 200,000 premature deaths from lung cancer and heart disease, according to an unpublished International Maritime Organisation (IMO) study.


Fatalities from illnesses such as asthma were not covered by the leaked paper, which was based on shipping satellite data and modelling work.


The shipping industry is by far the world’s biggest emitter of sulphur with SOx levels in heavy fuel oils up to 3,500 times higher than those in current European diesel standards for vehicles. A single large cruise ship can reportedly burn as much fuel as whole towns, and emit more sulphur than 7m cars.


At the end of October, an IMO meeting in London will decide whether to cap the sulphur content of shipping fuels by 2020 or 2025. Current levels can reach 3.5% but the cap would limit them to 0.5%.


The 2020 deadline faces fierce resistance from the oil and gas industry association, IPIECA, and Bimco, a global shipping group, which argue that there is not enough low-sulphur fuel available to meet the global demand that the measure would spur.


The EU has thrown its weight behind 2020, unilaterally imposing the new IMO standard from then. With China enforcing similar emissions control zones, the new benchmark for 2020 is thought likely to pass, although the US and large flag states’ positions remain wildcards.


James Corbett, one of the report’s lead authors, told the Guardian that any slippage on the 2020 start date risked grave consequences.


“An IMO policy implemented on time in 2020 could reduce the health burden on coastal communities, particularly in Asia, Africa and Latin America,” he said. “The inverse is also true. A delay would ensure that health impacts from sulphur emissions persisted in coastal communities that are exposed, where shipping lanes are most intense and communities most densely populated.”


Egypt, Panama, Japan, India, Singapore, the Philippines and China would be among the countries hardest hit, Corbett added.


Sveinung Oftedal, Norway’s lead negotiator at the IMO, said that domestic health concerns had now overtaken fears about the acidifying effects that sulphur has on Scandinavia’s lakes and rivers.


“Air pollution from shipping is not just a local or regional, but a global, problem,” he said. “The question is whether we can really continue to accept its effects, and the answer is: no, we cannot. The 2020 deadline is needed and it is achievable.”


But resentment in the beleaguered shipping trade is unmistakeable, and a sign of future fights to come in the IMO over shipping’s CO2 emissions, which roughly equal those from aviation.


“Most shipping companies are not turkeys voting for Christmas,” an industry source said. “They’re under the impression that a decision to delay to 2025 would be of collective economic benefit. In the real world, shipowners are bleeding money. There is total depression in the industry.”


Thousands of container ships belonging to Hanjin, south Korea’s biggest shipping firm, were left adrift on the world’s oceans carrying a £14bn cargo, after the firm filed for bancruptcy last month.


The International Chambers of Shipping (ICS) says that imposing the new benchmark in 2020 would cost industry an additional $ 50-100bn a year, owing to the cost of low-sulphur fuels.


Ships today mostly run on cheap blends of the residues and remainders left over from the refining and distillation of crude oil for aircraft jet fuel and automobile diesel.


Bimco argues that a premature move to low-sulphur fuels could have knock-on inflationary effects for other fuels, as increased diesel demand overwhelms supply.


Lars Robert Pedersen, Bimco’s deputy secretary-general, told the Guardian: “Quite frankly, if the IMO decides to ignore these very concrete facts, ships will start to use other fuel streams and there will then obviously be a shortage in those streams and a potential disruption in the flow of energy to supply world markets.”


Corbett estimates the total cost of the measure at $ 30bn, compared to a value of seaborne trade approaching $ 5tn in the South China Sea alone. Supporters of an early sulphur cap say that its effect on commodity prices such as shoes or bananas would be little more than a few cents.


Crucially, a second IMO report seen by the Guardian finds that enough refineries will be available in 2020 to guarantee the future availability of a low-sulphur fuel supply for all the world’s ships.


“In all scenarios, the refinery sector has the capability to supply sufficient quantities of marine fuels with a sulphur content of 0.5% m/m or less … to meet demand for these products, while also meeting demand for non-marine fuels,” it says.


A capacity shortage in 2020 would be the only grounds for IMO delegates to delay the proposal, under its terms of reference, which some fear could then be extended indefinitely.


In a reflection of differing opinions in the sea freight trade, the ICS is neutral on the timeline for phasing out sulphur, while calling for a speedy resolution of the issue.


The oil industry too is ambivalent. One analyst with close knowledge of the issue said: “Major oil companies such as Shell and BP don’t have a problem with a move to cleaner fuel in the shipping sector because they have advanced refineries which could sell higher value fuels and increase their revenues and potentially, their profits.”


Later this month, a global CO2 data collection system for ships will be launched. Neither shipping nor aviation firms are covered by the Paris climate agreement, although the ICS has called for the UN’s climate pledging system to be extended to the industry.



Delay to curbs on toxic shipping emissions "would cause 200,000 extra premature deaths"

24 Nisan 2014 Perşembe

Halving meat and dairy consumption could slash farming emissions

Herd of cattle with calves near Doonbeg, County Clare

Cutting meat and dairy consumption in half would also lead to a forty% minimize in Europeans’ consumption of saturated fats. Photograph: Tim Graham/Getty Photos




Greenhouse gas emissions from agriculture would be reduce by 25-forty% if Europeans lower their meat and dairy consumption by half, in accordance to a UN report.


Scientists from the UN Financial Commission for Europe say that as nicely as cutting air and water pollution, adopting a “demitarian diet program” – cutting meat and dairy consumption in half – would lead to a forty% reduce in Europeans’ intake of saturated fats.


The huge majority of saturated fats come from animal items that can lead to cholesterol troubles and weight problems, and this kind of a lower would deliver amounts to within a variety recommended by the Globe Health Organisation.


Prof Mark Sutton, one particular of the authors who coined the term demitarian and is one particular himself, explained regardless of strong farming lobbies it was not “pie in the sky” to envisage this kind of a cut in meat consumption. But he said the staff was not taking a position on how very best to encourage men and women to modify their meals routines.


“When we have seen people urged to be vegetarians I have personally witnessed that that can lead to a backlash since several individuals want to eat meat. From the environmental level of view, it truly is not about no matter whether you eat meat or dairy, it truly is about how significantly,” he said in London on Thursday.


The report, Nitrogen on the Table, examined the impacts that modifications in buyer food routines would have on nitrogen emissions from livestock. It mentioned a 50% cut in meat and dairy consumption would reduce greenhouse gasoline emissions by 25-40% depending on what the freed-up land was utilised for. The volume of imported soybeans, largely used to feed livestock, would fall by 75%.


The taskforce concluded that the amount of nitrogen misplaced into the wider setting – into the air and into water – was 25 instances larger per unit of meals protein from beef than for cereals.


Nitrous oxide is a single of the most strong greenhouse gases, far a lot more potent than carbon dioxide. Nitrogen releases from agriculture have other negative environmental results, mixing with emissions from cars to develop small particulate pollution that is damaging to people. When it runs off farmland into rivers it can end up in the sea and cause algal blooms.


A dramatic reduction in meat and dairy farming – which would meet sturdy opposition from farming bodies in the Uk – would also free of charge up land either for expanding cereals or biofuels, the UN team mentioned.


“The EU could grow to be a significant exporter of food items, alternatively of a key importer of, for example, soybeans,” said Henk Westhoek, the report’s lead writer and programme manager at the Netherlands Atmosphere Assessment Company.


But he admitted that drastically lowering cattle farming would not in all instances free-up land appropriate for expanding cereal crops rather. “It would not be favourable to take out all the beef manufacturing since then we can’t use all our organic and semi-natural grasslands,” he mentioned.


Dr Diane Mitchell, chief atmosphere adviser at the Nationwide Farmers Union, said: “Farmers and land managers have currently taken fantastic measures to decreasing its use by way of much better management and efficiency – in fact, its use is down considerably over the previous 20 years.


“Eating significantly less meat is a simplistic answer to what is a extremely complex situation. Agricultural production in the Uk is currently responsible for close to 10% of complete United kingdom greenhouse gasoline emissions and the British livestock and dairy sectors are already doing much to tackle their greenhouse fuel footprint. And it mustn’t be forgotten that meat and dairy products are an critical element of a wholesome, balanced diet plan.


She added: “More, the view that agricultural land must be taken away from livestock for other generate is nonsensical – some of this land can only be utilized for pasture and at the identical time goes some way to safeguarding our superb countryside.”


Sutton also speculated on the cultural influence that this kind of a move by Europe would have elsewhere about the world, in which meat consumption is growing quickly. One particular-third of the world’s meat now comes from China, where meat consumption per man or woman is headed towards US and European ranges.


“I would posit a hypothesis that if Europe were to make such a change that would have this kind of cultural ripples that it would have interactions with other parts of the globe. Nobody can tell the Chinese or anybody else what they need to be doing but if we have been to modify our culture, that would have a ripple, it would be an outstanding sea alter,” he stated.


The executive summary of the report was published on Friday, with the full report following up coming month. It follows a major assessment in 2011 by the exact same staff, which concluded that the annual cost of nitrogen pollution was in the region of £62bn-£282bn.


A spokesperson for the Department for Atmosphere, Meals and Rural Affairs said: “We’re operating with farmers to lessen greenhouse gasoline emissions, and we just lately launched a £4.5m initiative to support farmers turn into more environmentally sustainable. We’re also four years into an ambitious £12m analysis programme to improve our knowing of how we can lessen the affect of agriculture on emissions.”




Halving meat and dairy consumption could slash farming emissions